Remember staying glued to your TV to see Tyra Banks tell someone their picture was fierce… or not? America’s Next Top Model ran for 24 cycles (think: seasons, but make it fashion) with 322 episodes over 15 years, pulling in 100+ million viewers at its peak. Now, two decades later, Netflix dropped a docuseries that cracks open what was happening behind those judging panel doors. 👀

What We Watched vs What We Missed

“Reality Check: Inside America’s Next Top Model” dropped in mid-February 2026 with three episodes to stream. Tyra Banks, the original judges, and a lineup of former contestants sit down to share what was unfolding off-camera. 

The Judges: Reunions and Receipts

🎬 Tyra Banks participated as a subject only (not as a producer) and frames her legacy as someone who set out to disrupt the fashion industry. She hints at a possible Cycle 25 reboot. What the doc doesn’t let slide: Tyra hasn’t visited Miss J. Alexander since his stroke. 

💃 Miss J. Alexander (Runway Coach, Cycles 1-11) is the documentary’s most emotional storyline. On December 27, 2022, he suffered a massive stroke that left him in a coma for five weeks and hospitalized for over a year. As of filming, he still cannot walk. “I taught models how to walk,” he says. “And now I can’t walk. Not yet.” He reunites on camera with Jay Manuel and Nigel Barker, both of whom visited him in the hospital. 

📸 Jay Manuel (Creative Director, Cycles 1-11) already hinted at behind-the-scenes tensions in his 2020 book. The doc picks up where that left off, with Manuel reflecting on the show’s power dynamics. His contract (along with those of Miss J and Nigel Barker)  was not renewed in 2012, all of which gets addressed.

📷 Nigel Barker (Cycles 2-11) offers some of the doc’s quieter revelations, including his perspective on the 2012 contract. He currently works as a photographer and filmmaker.

🚫 Janice Dickinson (self-proclaimed “World’s First Supermodel”) is conspicuously absent and was reportedly tied up on another project. She has publicly claimed she was fired after alleging Tyra incorporated ideas from her book (including the famous “smize”) without credit. Tyra has never addressed it. The directors noted: “The beauty of social media is I’m sure we’ll be hearing from her.” 

The Contestants: Who Did (and Didn’t) Go On the Record

🌟 Shandi Sullivan (Cycle 2) shares that a man invited by production to the models’ house in Milan allegedly sexually assaulted her, but the show framed it as cheating and filmed the entire confrontation with her boyfriend, including his explosive reaction. Consent was never mentioned. Shandi later asked Tyra not to re-air that footage on her talk show but she did anyway. Today Shandi co-hosts a horror podcast Urn Fulla Popcorn. She says the pain “hasn’t gone away.”

🍦 Whitney Thompson (Cycle 10) was labeled “plus-size” at a size 6 and 5’10”. She said production routinely refused to provide her clothes that fit and she took Xanax before every judging panel. Whitney calls the experience a “nightmare,” but also credits it with opening doors for curvy models. Today she owns an ice cream shop and has retired from modeling.

🏀 Dani Evans (Cycle 6 winner) revisits the pressure to close her iconic tooth gap to stay competitive, only for Tyra to later widen a white contestant’s gap by choice. She now describes herself as a “proud basketball mom.”

🍔 Keenyah Hill (Cycle 4) recounts a South Africa photoshoot where a male model acted aggressively toward her, she tried to stop it and was dismissed by producers. She’s best remembered for the infamous “eat a burger, take the bread off” exchange, which she says unfairly became her entire narrative.

🦷 Joanie Sprague (Cycle 6) had multiple teeth removed as part of a makeover challenge. A medical procedure. Done as TV content. The doc doesn’t let that one pass quietly, nor should it.

The absences of these two contestants tell their own story:

Winnie Harlow (Cycle 21) is the show’s most successful alum by every measurable metric: Victoria’s Secret runway, Beyoncé’s Lemonade, Vogue covers, campaigns for Marc Jacobs and Fendi, her own beauty brand Cay Skin, and 10 million-plus Instagram followers — more than Tyra herself. She placed sixth and has said ANTM “really didn’t do anything for my career.” 

Adrianne Curry (Cycle 1 winner — the original) declined publicly and loudly posting that she found “people psychoanalyzing it over 20 years later with a woke lens [is] absurd.” She has since posted a partial defense of Tyra while still refusing to participate. Adrianne now lives “off the grid” in Montana. 

The Bottom Line

A show that claimed to break fashion barriers produced its most successful alum in someone has made clear she doesn’t owe it anything. Three episodes of “Reality Check” can only cover so much ground around accountability and beauty standards. A separate E! docuseries is reportedly in development. Stay tuned. 

Related: Bath & Body Works’ Rose Redux: Dark & Moody to Sweet & Romantic